Who's publishing DMARC?

DMARC is a way for a domain owner to say “If you see this domain in a From: header and it’s not been sent straight from us, please don’t deliver the mail”. If a domain is only used for bulk and transactional mail, it can mitigate a subset of phishing attacks without causing too many problems for legitimate email.
In other cases, it can cause significant problems. Some of those problems impact discussion lists, but others cause problems for ESPs servicing small companies and individuals. ESP customers use their email addresses in the From: field; if they’re a small customer using the email address provided by their ISP, and that ISP publishes a DMARC record with p=reject, a large chunk of the mail they’re sending will bounce. When that happens recipients will stop getting their email, they’ll be removed from the mailing list due to bounces, and there’s some risk of blocks being raised against the sending IP address.
Because of that, it’s good to be able to see what consumer ISPs are doing with DMARC.
I’ve created a tool at dmarc.wordtothewise.com that regularly checks a list of large consumer ISPs and webmail providers and sees what DMARC records they’re publishing.
There are two main variants of DMARC records.
One is policy “reject” – meaning that mail that isn’t authenticated (or for which authentication has been broken in transit) will likely be rejected.
The other is policy “none” – meaning that the ISP publishing the record doesn’t want recipients to change their delivery decisions, but are asking for feedback about their mailstream, and how much of it fails authentication. That can mean that the ISP is evaluating whether or not to publish p=REJECT, or is in the process of deploying p=REJECT. Or it can just mean that they’re using DMARC to monitor where mail using their domain in the From: address is being sent from. There’s no way to tell which is the case unless they’ve made an announcement about their plans.
Hopefully this will be a useful tool to monitor DMARC deployment by consumer ISPs, and to help diagnose delivery problems that may be caused by DMARC.

Cryptography with Alice and Bob
Alice and Bob Sign Messages

Related Posts

ReturnPath on DMARC+Yahoo

Over at ReturnPath Christine has an excellent non-technical summary of the DMARC+Yahoo situation, along with some solid recommendations for what actions you might take to avoid the operational problems it can cause.

Read More

AOL admits to security breach

According to Reuters AOL has admitted there was a breach of their network security that compromised 2% of their accounts. Users are being told to reset their passwords, and security questions.
AOL started investigating the attack after users started reporting an uptick in spam from aol.com addresses. This spam was using @aol.com addresses to send mail to addresses in that user’s address book.
According to the AOL mail team, they are still investigating the attack, but they do not believe financial information was compromised.  Their statement reads in part:

Read More

AOL publishes a p=reject DMARC record

Yesterday I mentioned that there were reports of a compromise at AOL. While the details are hazy, what has been reported is that people’s address books were stolen. The reports suggest lots of people are getting mail from AOL addresses that they have received mail from in the past, but that mail is coming from non AOL servers. In an apparent effort to address this, AOL announced today they have published a p=reject DMARC record.
I expect this also means that AOL is now checking and listening to DMARC records on the inbound. During the discussions of who was checking DMARC during the Yahoo discussion, AOL was not one of the ISPs respecting DMARC policy statements. I’m not surprised. As more information started coming out about this compromise, I figured that the folks attacking Yahoo had moved on to AOL and that AOL’s response would be similar to Yahoo’s.
My prediction is that the attackers will be trying to get into Outlook.com and Gmail, and when they do, those ISPs will follow suit in publishing p=reject messages. For those of you wondering what DMARC is about, you can check out my DMARC primer.

Read More