"Blocked for Bot-like Behavior"

An ESP asked about this error message from Hotmail and what to do about it.
“Bot-like” behaviour usually means the sending server is doing something that bots also do. It’s not always that they’re spamming, often it’s a technical issue. But the technical problems make the sending server look like a bot, so the ISP is not taking any chances and they’re going to stop accepting mail from that server.
If you’re an ESP what should you look for when tracking down what the problem is?
First make sure your server isn’t infected with anything and that you’re not running an open relay or proxy. Second, make sure your customers aren’t compromised or have had their accounts hijacked.
Then start looking at your configuration.
HELO/EHLO values

  • are you using a consistent one for each IP or are the values changing?
  • are you using a FQDN (fully qualified domain name, i.e., a.example.com) for the HELO?
  • are you using a bare IP for the HELO/EHLO?
  • does that FQDN match the rDNS of the IP?

IP issues

  • does your IP have rDNS?
  • does that rDNS in any way look like it might be dynamic?
  • how many IPs are you using to send the same message?

Header issues

  • are you using a consistent hostname in the envelope From?
  • is that hostname similar to the hostname in the IP address?
  • are you sending a MessageID?
  • are you authenticating?
  • is that authentication correct?

Content

  • are you sending small amounts of the same content over different IP addresses?
  • is the content you’re sending being sent by other entities?
  • are any of the URLs you’re linking to infected with anything?
  • are any of the URLs you’re linking to serving ads that might be spreading viruses?

Sending issues

  • are you closing connections promptly or are you holding them open?
  • are you opening connections from different IPs and sending the same content at the same time?

The major bot-like behaviours are sending small numbers of messages from many different IP addresses, and using bad HELO/EHLO values. Even small senders using shared pools can trigger this filter at Hotmail. Try not to split small volumes of mail over multiple IPs whenever possible and particularly when you are getting this error message.
 
 

Ken gets spam
Major payday loan email sender shut down

Related Posts

Hotmail moves to SPF authentication

Hotmail has recently stopped using Sender ID for email authentication and switched to authenticating with SPF. The protocol differences between SenderID and SPF were subtle and most senders who were getting a pass at Hotmail were already publishing SPF records.
From an email in my inbox from September:

Read More

DNS Changer servers going offline

There are a whole host of different botnets. One botnet run by Rove Digital infected computers with viruses that changed their DNS settings, giving the botnet runners the ability to control how the infected computers viewed the Internet.
The criminals behind the DNS Changer virus were arrested in November of last year. The court ordered the Internet Systems Consortium (ISC) to operate replacement DNS servers for computers infected with the botnet viruses in order to give users a chance to clean and fix their computers.
That court order expires on Monday.
Anyone who is still infected with the DNS Changer malware will see their internet services greatly curtailed when the DNS servers go offline.
If you run Windows and you haven’t yet checked to see if you’re infected, you should do so soon. There are a number of websites you can visit that will tell you if you are actually infected with the DNS changer virus and if you are will give you information on how to fix your system.

Read More

Cloudflare and Spamhaus

Spamhaus has been the subject of a lot of discussion the last few weeks. I touched on this a little in June when I blogged that a number of large brands were getting SBL listings.
But big brands are not the only companies with publicly discussed SBL listings.
Cloudflare, the content delivery network that grew out of project honeypot, has a number of SBL listings, covering at least 2 /18s and a /20. Representatives and customers of Cloudflare have been discussing the listings on twitter.
As a content provider, Cloudflare isn’t actually sending mail nor are they actually hosting the content. What they are doing is providing consistent name service and traffic routing to malicious websites. In fact, they’ve been providing services to a malware botnet controller (SBL138291) since May, 2012. They’re also providing services to a number of SEO spammers. Both of these actions are justification for a SBL listing, and Spamhaus has a history of listing providers protecting spammers.
Cloudflare claims they take action on all “properly filed complaints” and they may actually do that. But their reports require quite a bit of information and require consent for releasing information to 3rd parties. Looking at the website, it appears to me to be a site designed to discourage abuse reports and stop people from reporting problems to Cloudflare.
When you look at the Cloudflare business model it’s clearly one that will be abused. Cloudflare acts as a reverse proxy / pass through network that caches data from their customers. This protects the abusers webhosting setup and prevents people tracking the abuser from being able to determine the true host of a website. As a responsible internet citizen, Cloudflare should be disconnecting the customers hiding behind Cloudflare’s services.
Unfortunately, Cloudflare seems unwilling to actually police their customers. They’ve taken a totally hands off approach.
Let’s be frank. Cloudflare has been providing service to Botnet C&C servers for at least two months. It doesn’t matter that the abuser has the malware on a machine elsewhere, Cloudflare’s IP is the one that serves the data. I don’t care what you think about spam, providing service to malware providers is totally unacceptable. It’s even more unacceptable when you claim to be a security company. Nothing about malware is legitimate and the fact that Cloudflare is continuing to host a malware network command and control node is concerning at the very least.
Cloudflare (.pdf) is listed on Spamhaus for providing spam support services. The most obvious of these is providing service to a malware controller. And Spamhaus escalated the listings because they are allowing other abusers to hide behind their reverse proxy.

Read More