Going out of business email strategies

Chad White of Smith-Harmon posted a report today on shutting down email marketing programs when going out of business. He looks in detail at how a number of companies handled their email marketing during the going-out-of-business process. There is a very solid mix of examples of how companies handle things. Some companies do things very badly, like never mention over email that they’re going out of business or neglect to follow CAN SPAM regulations. Others used their list as a communications tool that survived the dissolution of the parent company.
The full report is well worth a read, but the take home messages are clear.

First, your email program can play a critical role in alerting your subscribers to changes in operations, winding down operations or liquidation sales.
Oddly, bankrupt retailers usually give anonymous website visitors more information that they give to email subscribers. This is a huge missed opportunity to drive sales, and it’s also disrespectful to your brands’ most loyal customers. The time during which you’re liquidating or exploring your options is a poor time to alienate dedicated subscribers.
And second, and even more importantly, brands that appear to be headed for extinction often find a second life. Examples include the rebirth of Pets.com as a community site run by PetSmart, the takeover of CompUSA.com by TigerDirect parent Systemax, and the rescue of RedEnvelope by new owners. Because of this, maintaining email relationships with your best customers is critical to preserving the value of your brand as much as possible during a transaction.

One thing that was clear to me while I was looking at the report, is that the companies who did things badly weren’t thinking about email marketing as one of their assets during the shutdown process. In one case, the company never even mentioned they were going out of business in their email marketing, the mail just stopped one day. This same company prominently mentioned the going out of business on their website, so it was clearly a failure of the marketing department to communicate over email.
As an aside, Smith-Harmon have their own email marketing program well managed. When I downloaded the report, I agreed to receive email from them. Within 5 minutes of me signing up for the program I received a welcome message welcoming me to the program, giving me some real content and not relying on images. Kudos to them for walking the walk.

Related Posts

Brand name spam

I’ve been getting a lot more spam advertising name brand companies. Places like FTD Flowers, Seattle Coffee Direct, Wal-Mart, Jet Blue, Gevalia and VistaPrint seem to all be working with spammers. In some cases, I am getting the same email to different email addresses from different domains and different IP addresses.
I am sure, if asked, all the advertised companies would say they have no knowledge of spamming by their vendors. I’m sure they would say that their vendors tell them I opted in to the email and must have just forgotten. I am sure that this isn’t really spam.
Except it really is spam. Real companies with real brands do use the services of spammers. When caught they loudly protest their innocence and talk about rogue affiliates. In the best cases they will “fire” the affiliate and then look the other way when the affiliate signs back up.
Spam is sending mail to people who never requested it. Hiring someone to do it for you doesn’t mean you aren’t a spammer. With the economy tanking and companies trying to maximize their bottom line, more and more name brands seem to be jumping on the spam bandwagon. It is not an unexpected development, but it will mean more aggressive spam filtering and more difficult email delivery for everyone.

Read More

Poor delivery is not always about spam

There are days I think we have trained people too well to believe every delivery problem is a misplaced spam block. We also have people trained to expect near 100% immediate delivery from send to inbox.
The problem is, email isn’t 100% reliable. It’s close. Very close. But sometimes mail just fails. It’s not because the ISPs hate you. It’s sometimes not even because the mail looks like spam.
Sometimes Mail Just Fails.
One of the challenges of working in email delivery is knowing enough to be able to separate out the random delivery failures from real delivery issues.

Read More

Subscribers notice what marketers do

Stephanie Miller from RP blogs at EEC about a UK consumer survey with the take home message: “consumers notice what email marketers do. When we send something interesting and relevant at a good pace, they are happy to stay active with our programs. When we don’t… well, then we’ve lost them, perhaps for good.”

Read More